No Return
July 10, 2026 at 04:30PMWillian Finnegan folds the story of a fatal mountaineering expedition into a courtroom drama, with each narrative track just as tense as the other. Last year, Kerstin Gurtner froze to death on Grossglockner, an Austrian mountain whose peak extends more than 12,000 feet above the Adriatic Sea. Her boyfriend and climbing partner, Thomas Plamberger, was charged with grossly negligent homicide. Finnegan, no stranger to climbing himself, is an attentive, critical presence in the courtroom, questioning the role of “mountain-man obtuseness” in a lethal misadventure. The question that ghosts this story: When does self-reliance begin to interfere with our obligations to others?
Thomas seems to admire the early alpine first ascenders, at least online. But his relationship with the modern outdoor industry feels vexed. On an Instagram post where a Matterhorn guide advertised his services, Thomas wrote tauntingly, “Why would I book something like that? I’ll climb it myself.” In 2023, when a skier named Eva Walkner posted about a tremendous day with a film crew on a mountain called Hoher Göll, Thomas commented appreciatively, then asked why her party hadn’t gone higher up the face. The footage attached to the post makes it obvious why not: there were massive snow cornices near the top, and the avalanche danger was already considerable where they stopped. What’s not obvious is whether Thomas knew that Eva Walkner is a two-time Freeride World Champion. Her profile has spectacular clips of her flying off terrifying cliffs and skiing out unfazed. Two years later, when Thomas’s name was in the news, Walkner came back to the post and answered his question: “Why did we turn around just before the summit? Because turning back when conditions become too dangerous is what distinguishes good and experienced alpinists.”
from Longreads https://longreads.com/2026/07/10/grossglockner-thomasplamberger-kerstin-gurtner-climbing-death/
via IFTTT
Watch